Best Alternative to Spreadsheets for Churches
ChurchTrac VS Spreadsheets
Key Takeaways:
- Spreadsheets are great short-term record keeping solution for churches just getting started.
- Spreadsheets quickly become disjointed and pose a significant security threat for churches.
Strengths of ChurchTrac and Spreadsheets
Spreadsheets or Excel sheets tend to be a good fit for small churches needing a fast and temporary solution for tracking member and giving data. ChurchTrac offers a permanent solution to for ministries of all sizes.
ChurchTrac excels if:
- You want an affordable system for everything.
- You want a church software that offers accounting and websites.
- You're a small or mid-size church that values simplicity.
Spreadsheets excel if:
- You just need to store basic data on a handful of people.
- You're looking for a simple solution for tracking giving on a few dozen people.
- You're creating a specific spreadsheet for a specific ministry purpose.
Pros and Cons of each
Though spreadsheets are free and easy to use, ChurchTrac is often a better long-term solution that also includes additional features that spreadsheets don't offer.
| Platform | Pros | Cons |
| Spreadsheets |
|
|
| ChurchTrac |
|
|
ChurchTrac & Spreadsheet Features Compared
Outside of storing basic data for members and finances, ChurchTrac offers features that go far beyond a typical excel spreadsheet.
| Feature | ChurchTrac | Spreadsheets |
| People Management | ✅ Included | ⚠️ Limited Capability |
| Attendance Tracking | ✅ Included | ⚠️ Limited Capability |
| Calendar & Events | ✅ Included | ⚠️ Limited Capability |
| Check-In | ✅ Included | ❌ (Unavailable) |
| Worship Planning | ✅ Included | ❌ (Unavailable) |
| Emailing & Messaging | ✅ Included | ❌ (Unavailable) |
| Donation Tracking | ✅ Included | ⚠️ Limited Capability |
| Online Giving | ✅ Included | ❌ (Unavailable) |
| Church Accounting | ⚠️ (Available add-on) | ⚠️ Limited Capability |
| Church Website Hosting | ✅ Included | ❌ (Unavailable) |
| Church App | ✅ Included | ❌ (Unavailable) |
ChurchTrac VS Spreadsheet Pricing
ChurchTrac is an affordable option for churches. However, spreadsheet programs like Google Sheets and Numbers are available for free.
| Church Size | ChurchTrac (with accounting) | Church Spreadsheets |
| 75 People | $24/month | Free |
| 125 People | $33/month | Free |
| 250 People | $51/month | Free |
| 500 People | $69/month | Free |
| 1,000 People | $87/month | Free |
| Unlimited | $105/month | Free |
The Hidden Cost of Spreadsheets for Churches: Time
It's true, you can run most functions of a church with a mix of different spreadsheets. There are numerous free Excel templates for church giving, accounting, membership, and scheduling. But when you compare these templates to a purpose built church software, the time savings is significant.
A platform like ChurchTrac can save you hours every month for:
- Volunteer Scheduling
- Church Bookkeeping
- Donation Tracking
- Membership Management
Why Churches Switch From Spreadsheets To ChurchTrac
Churches switching to ChurchTrac from Excel sheets often cite time savings or ease-of-use for making the switch. Here are a few real reviews:
ChurchTrac is easier to use, cheaper, and has a better app. — Bill H, Senior Pastor (Source: Capterra)
"ChurchTrac was much more cost effective, and much more intuitive to use." — Stephanie F, Church Secretary (Source: Capterra)
