ChurchTrac Logo ChurchTrac Logo
Help & Resources
Help Center
Browse answers, or connect with our team
Watch our Videos
Watch our tutorials and live streams
Read the Blog
News, tips and the latest happenings
Hear Our Story
The 9 things that make us unique
Explore Plans & Pricing
Affordable options for every church
Pricing
Help Center
Browse answers, or connect with our team
Watch our Videos
Watch our tutorials and live streams
Read the Blog
News, tips and the latest happenings
Hear Our Story
The 9 things that make us unique
Explore Plans & Pricing
Affordable options for every church
Login
Start For Free
 Comparisons  /  Best Alternative to Spreadsheets for Churches

Best Alternative to Spreadsheets for Churches

ChurchTrac VS Spreadsheets

Key Takeaways:

  • Spreadsheets are great short-term record keeping solution for churches just getting started.
  • Spreadsheets quickly become disjointed and pose a significant security threat for churches.
Best Alternative to Spreadsheets for Churches

Strengths of ChurchTrac and Spreadsheets

Spreadsheets or Excel sheets tend to be a good fit for small churches needing a fast and temporary solution for tracking member and giving data. ChurchTrac offers a permanent solution to for ministries of all sizes.

ChurchTrac excels if:

  • You want an affordable system for everything.
  • You want a church software that offers accounting and websites.
  • You're a small or mid-size church that values simplicity.

Spreadsheets excel if:

  • You just need to store basic data on a handful of people.
  • You're looking for a simple solution for tracking giving on a few dozen people.
  • You're creating a specific spreadsheet for a specific ministry purpose.

Pros and Cons of each

Though spreadsheets are free and easy to use, ChurchTrac is often a better long-term solution that also includes additional features that spreadsheets don't offer.

Platform Pros Cons
Spreadsheets
  • Great for churches needing to record basic data.
  • Free to use and highly customizable.
  • Very limited functionality outside of storing basic data and finances.
  • Church data can easily be copied and compromised.
ChurchTrac
  • All-In-One approach provides a great value for churches wanting to save money.
  • More customizable data storage for all of your church's info.
  • ChurchTrac's All-In-One approach may include features some churches don't need.
  • Can feel like overkill for a church with less than a few dozn members.

 

ChurchTrac & Spreadsheet Features Compared

Outside of storing basic data for members and finances, ChurchTrac offers features that go far beyond a typical excel spreadsheet.

Feature ChurchTrac Spreadsheets 
People Management ✅ Included ⚠️ Limited Capability
Attendance Tracking ✅ Included ⚠️ Limited Capability
Calendar & Events ✅ Included ⚠️ Limited Capability
Check-In ✅ Included ❌ (Unavailable)
Worship Planning ✅ Included ❌ (Unavailable)
Emailing & Messaging ✅ Included ❌ (Unavailable)
Donation Tracking ✅ Included ⚠️ Limited Capability
Online Giving ✅ Included ❌ (Unavailable)
Church Accounting ⚠️ (Available add-on) ⚠️ Limited Capability
Church Website Hosting ✅ Included ❌ (Unavailable)
Church App ✅ Included ❌ (Unavailable)

ChurchTrac VS Spreadsheet Pricing

ChurchTrac is an affordable option for churches. However, spreadsheet programs like Google Sheets and Numbers are available for free.

Church Size ChurchTrac (with accounting) Church Spreadsheets
75 People $24/month Free
125 People $33/month Free
250 People $51/month Free
500 People $69/month Free
1,000 People $87/month Free
Unlimited $105/month Free

The Hidden Cost of Spreadsheets for Churches: Time

It's true, you can run most functions of a church with a mix of different spreadsheets. There are numerous free Excel templates for church giving, accounting, membership, and scheduling. But when you compare these templates to a purpose built church software, the time savings is significant.

A platform like ChurchTrac can save you hours every month for:

  • Volunteer Scheduling
  • Church Bookkeeping
  • Donation Tracking
  • Membership Management

Why Churches Switch From Spreadsheets To ChurchTrac

Churches switching to ChurchTrac from Excel sheets often cite time savings or ease-of-use for making the switch. Here are a few real reviews:

 

ChurchTrac is easier to use, cheaper, and has a better app. — Bill H, Senior Pastor (Source: Capterra)
"ChurchTrac was much more cost effective, and much more intuitive to use." — Stephanie F, Church Secretary (Source: Capterra)

ChurchTrac ranked #1 church software

Start your free trial

Explore ChurchTrac for yourself by starting a free 30 day trial.

Get Started Now
ChurchTrac Logo

Your All-In-One Church Software.

Facebook Twitter Youtube Vimeo

Products & Features

Donations and Online Giving Church Website Builder Church App Builder People & Messaging Events & Attendance Child Check-In Church Automations Church Accounting Worship and Scheduling Custom Built Websites Accounting Service Security & Integrations

How We Compare

ChurchTrac vs Planning Center ChurchTrac vs Tithe.ly ChurchTrac vs Breeze ChurchTrac vs QuickBooks ChurchTrac vs Aplos See all comparisons

Software Solutions

For Church Plants For Small Churches For Mid-Size Churches See more solutions

Company

About ChurchTrac Terms of Service Privacy Policy Copyright Policy

Quick Links

Login to Your Account ChurchTrac Pricing Start a Trial Getting Started Join a Live Demo Contact Us | Tech Support

Recent Posts

  • The Best Teen Study Bibles
  • The Best Giving Platform for Small to Mid-Size Churches?
  • Common Scams That Target Churches — How To Protect Yours
  • PraiseCharts Integration and Worship Enhancements
  • Best Study Bible for Beginners
  • View more blog posts...