Best Alternative to Tithe.ly [2026]

Strengths of ChurchTrac and Tithely

Tithely and ChurchTrac both excel for churches looking for more of an all in one solution.

ChurchTrac excels if:

• You want one affordable system for everything.
• You want a platform that offers accounting and websites.
• You’re a church that values simplicity and value.

Tithely excels if:

• Your a church is looking for a free online giving app.
• Your church is looking for a platform with simple pricing.
• Your church is needing a platform that includes an app and website.

Pros and Cons of each Platform

Tithely and ChurchTrac offer many similar features. Tithely offers a more giving centric model while ChurchTrac is more focused on providing multiple ministry tools.

ChurchTrac & Tithely Features Compared

Both ChurchTrac and Tithely have nearly identical features. The biggest difference is that ChurchTrac offers an accounting tool while Tithely does not currently have a solution for expense tracking and budgeting.

Since Tithely does not include an church accounting module, churches will need to supplement Tithely with additional tools such as Quickbooks or Aplos.

ChurchTrac VS Tithe.ly Pricing

Compared to Tithely, ChurchTrac tends to be a better value for small to mid-size ministries.

What These Prices Mean for Small, Mid, and Large Churches.

When comparing the cost of ChurchTrac to Tithely, the price difference can range from a few hundred dollars to as much as $1,300 of dollars per year depending on the size and needs of a church.

For small churches (under 200 people):

Many small churches opt for Tithely's "all-access" bundle to get the best value and have access to all of the core features. This cost's $119/month or $1,428/year.

ChurchTrac’s entry plan starts at $24/month and already includes a church accounting module, which Tithely doesn't offer.

For mid-size churches (200–2,000 people):

Mid-sized ministries find Tithely's "all-access" pricing a good value with it's simple pricing of only $119/month.

ChurchTrac gives similar tools (plus accounting) for under $90/month. This equates to a savings of up to $500 per year that can be redirected to outreach or missions.

For large churches (2,000+ people):

Tithe.ly offers custom enterprise-level packages for larger churches (typically over 2,000 attendees), with pricing and terms that vary based on each church’s needs.

For large churches, ChurchTrac pricing stays consistent at around $105/month including the accounting add-on.

Reviews from churches that switched from Tithe.ly

Churches switching to ChurchTrac from Tithely often cite cost and features for making the switch. Here are a few real reviews:

"ChurchTrac had everything included into one package without the need to run extra software on the side for bookkeeping, worship planning, etc."
—Joshua S, Pastor (Source: Capterra)

"I like the fact that this program brings everything together in one place. I was previously using one program for the bank register, another for the app/website, and still another for church management. Now I only have to open one program!"
—Jana M, Treasurer (Source: Capterra)

According to Software Advice, ChurchTrac ranked #1 for customer satisfaction and usability.